How to Choose the Right Developmental Editor for Your Novel

{Without Losing Your Voice or Getting Stuck in Endless Rewrites}

Hire the wrong editor and you could lose months, your budget, and the version of your story you actually meant to tell. This guide makes sure that does not happen to you — written by a developmental editor who wants you asking her the same hard questions.

How to Choose the Right Developmental  Editor for Your Novel

Pop in your info here & I’ll send it straight to your inbox!

Hear it from other writers...SM

Hey! I just wanted to say I came across your ebook 50 Lessons and I loved it so much. I’m about to publish my first book this September, and honestly I’ve been feeling so overwhelmed and nervous wondering how readers will receive it and what they’ll think. Reading your lessons really calmed me down and made me feel understood. It helped me a lot, so thank you for sharing it! 💛

Thank you for reminding me that even an experienced author is just a writer-in-the-making, and that the fundamental truths of our craft are what truly matter. This isn’t just a book of lessons; it’s a therapeutic guide for any writer, new or seasoned, who needs to reconnect with their purpose.

There were so many days where I thought I lost myself but then I saw you and something shifted inside me. Your motto of never giving up actually motivated me and now I’m also going to learn and improve my skill under your lessons so thank you thank you soo much for showing in my life when I needed someone like you the most.🥹

Dear Srishti,

I’m writing to you with a heart full of gratitude for your “50 Lessons” eBook. As someone who has worked on numerous anthologies, published my own book, and contributed to magazines, I thought I had a handle on the writing process. But honestly, your book felt like a deep, personal conversation—a reflection of the silent struggles I still face, even with years of experience under my belt.

I’ve long been plagued by the ghost of perfectionism. Your lessons, especially about not trying to write a “perfect novel” and giving myself permission to write “bad stories,” felt like a direct response to my overthinking. I’ve been stuck on single scenes for weeks, caught in an endless loop of rewriting and judging every word before it even hits the page. You gave me the permission to just write the messy first draft, a reminder that a story must exist before it can ever be good.

Your book also forced me to confront my motivations. I’ve often felt the pressure to write what the “publishing market” wants and to build a massive “audience” to justify my work. Your lessons on letting go of those external pressures and focusing on my intrinsic purpose were profoundly freeing. They took me back to my “why”—the simple, pure joy of writing a story I want to see in the world, like one that celebrates the beauty of found family. It was a beautiful reminder that the creative journey is a personal one, regardless of a book’s reception or the number of people who follow you.

What’s waiting for YOU inside

What’s waiting for YOU inside
  • A clear definition of developmental editing

    Understand what happens inside a developmental edit and what you can expect from your editor {before you pay a single penny}.

  • A healthy vs. unhealthy author-editor relationship, side by side

    Recognize the difference before you're three months deep into a partnership that isn't working

  • The 12 questions to ask any editor before hiring them

    Get the only checklist you need before hop on a call with an editor, including the one big question I wish more authors asked me.

  • A readiness checklist for developmental editing

    Self-analyse whether or not you’re ready for the editorial process, and learn how to prepare yourself for it.

  • Different types of editorial feedback, explained with real examples

    Choose your editor based on a learning style that actually fits how you want to grow as a writer.

  • A real editorial process in practice

    Get a behind-the-scenes look at my own deliverables, post-edit support and other policies to gain full clarity on what the editing process actually feels like.

This guide is for you if...

  • 01

    You've finished a full draft and know it's time to hire a developmental editor, but you don't know what to ask them before you commit your money and your manuscript

  • 02

    You're evaluating a few different developmental editors right now and have no idea how to compare them beyond "who has the nicest website"

  • 03

    You're about to sign a contract with an editor and want to make sure it's the right fit before you're locked in

  • 04

    You've been burned before {or you've heard the horror stories} and you're done trusting the wrong person with your manuscript

Hey, I’m Srishti

Hey, I’m Srishti

I’m a fiction editor, story coach, and the founder of Kathansh, where I help women writers craft meaningful stories they’re genuinely proud to put their name on.

I wrote this guide because I’ve seen too many talented writers hand their manuscript {and their money} to the wrong person, not knowing what to look out for and what questions to ask first when hiring an editor. I’ve sat across from authors who were still struggling to fix the damage months later: feedback that flattened their voice, a process with zero structure and an editor who couldn’t explain why they suggested anything.

With an MFA in Creative Writing from the University of San Francisco and 80+ authors {170+ projects} behind me, I built this guide to be the conversation I wish every writer had before they signed a contract with any editor.

Hey, I’m Srishti